Looking for Halloween Would You Rather questions for kids? 🎃🍬 This list of 100 Halloween Would You Rather questions is packed with silly, funny, sweet, and kid-friendly choices!

Pin this for later!

• Pinterest

These questions are perfect for Halloween parties, classroom activities, family game nights, babysitting, homeschool, playdates, or simply getting kids talking during October.

And if your kids prefer a non-scary Halloween, you’re in the right place! These questions focus on candy, pumpkins, costumes, treats, games, crafts, fall activities, and silly Halloween adventures rather than scary or spooky themes.

🎃 How to Play Halloween Would You Rather

Playing is easy!

Simply read each question and have kids choose which option they would rather do. They can:

• Say their answer out loud
• Raise their hand for their choice
• Move to one side of the room
• Write down their answers
• Compare answers with friends
• Take turns asking the questions

There are no right or wrong answers. The fun comes from seeing what everyone chooses!

🎃 A Fun Twist for Larger Groups

Here is a unique way to use Would You Rather with a larger group of kids! Instead of simply having everyone answer the questions, use their answers to randomly sort them into teams.

Pick a series of Would You Rather questions and have the kids move around the room based on their answers. For example, if they choose the first option, have them move to the right side of the room. If they choose the second option, have them move to the left. Keep asking questions and have the kids switch sides each time based on their answers.

After several questions, you’ll suddenly have your teams!

The key is not to tell the kids that you’re using the game to choose teams. If they know ahead of time, they may try to stay with their friends instead of honestly choosing their answers. Just let them have fun answering the questions and moving around, then reveal the teams at the end!

🍬 100 Halloween Would You Rather Questions

Halloween Candy Questions

1. Would you rather have unlimited Reese’s Pumpkins or unlimited Kit Kats?
2. Would you rather have Sour Patch Kids or Nerds Gummy Clusters?
3. Would you rather have JOYRIDE candy or a Feastables chocolate bar?
4. Would you rather have chocolate candy or gummy candy?
5. Would you rather have candy for breakfast or candy for dessert?
6. Would you rather have one giant candy bar or 100 mini candy bars?
7. Would you rather have a candy store in your bedroom or a candy factory in your backyard?
8. Would you rather have a candy fountain or a chocolate fountain?
9. Would you rather eat only orange candy or only purple candy?
10. Would you rather get your favorite candy in every house or get a completely different candy at every house?
11. Would you rather have a bag full of chocolate or a bag full of gummies?
12. Would you rather have 100 pieces of candy or one piece of candy as big as your head?
13. Would you rather have your favorite candy grow on trees or grow in a garden?
14. Would you rather invent a new candy flavor or invent a new Halloween costume?
15. Would you rather have unlimited M&M’s or unlimited Skittles?
16. Would you rather have Twix or Snickers?
17. Would you rather have Airheads or Starburst?
18. Would you rather have Ring Pops or lollipops?
19. Would you rather have Nerds or Warheads?
20. Would you rather have a Halloween bag filled with your five favorite candies or 50 random candies?

🎃 Halloween Activities

21. Would you rather go trick-or-treating or decorate pumpkins?
22. Would you rather decorate Halloween cookies or make Halloween cupcakes?
23. Would you rather go on a candy scavenger hunt or play Halloween bingo?
24. Would you rather have a Halloween craft day or a Halloween games day?
25. Would you rather visit a pumpkin patch or go apple picking?
26. Would you rather decorate one giant pumpkin or 100 tiny pumpkins?
27. Would you rather have a Halloween movie night or a Halloween game night?
28. Would you rather make Halloween slime or make a Halloween craft?
29. Would you rather have a Halloween treasure hunt or a candy scavenger hunt?
30. Would you rather decorate your house with pumpkins or fall leaves?
31. Would you rather have a Halloween baking day or a Halloween art day?
32. Would you rather make the world’s biggest Halloween cookie or the world’s biggest caramel apple?
33. Would you rather have a pumpkin decorating contest or a costume contest?
34. Would you rather spend Halloween at a pumpkin patch or a giant candy store?
35. Would you rather have a Halloween sleepover or a Halloween daytime party?
36. Would you rather make Halloween donuts or Halloween cupcakes?
37. Would you rather paint pumpkins or decorate them with stickers?
38. Would you rather make Halloween friendship bracelets or Halloween necklaces?
39. Would you rather have a Halloween scavenger hunt or an outdoor Halloween obstacle course?
40. Would you rather play Halloween charades or Halloween Pictionary?

🍭 Funny Halloween Questions

41. Would you rather have to hop everywhere on Halloween or walk backward everywhere?
42. Would you rather have candy for hair or popcorn for shoes?
43. Would you rather have a pumpkin as big as your car or a candy bar as big as your arm?
44. Would you rather have candy rain from the sky or lemonade rain from the sky?
45. Would you rather have to wear your Halloween costume to school for a week or Halloween pajamas for a week?
46. Would you rather have a pumpkin that changes colors or one that grows overnight?
47. Would you rather have a candy bag that never gets full or a candy bowl that never runs out?
48. Would you rather have a pumpkin that follows you around or a candy bag that follows you around?
49. Would you rather have 100 tiny pumpkins or one enormous pumpkin?
50. Would you rather have your costume make funny sounds or light up?
51. Would you rather have to say “trick or treat” like a robot or like a movie star?
52. Would you rather have a pumpkin-shaped house or a candy-shaped house?
53. Would you rather have a giant marshmallow chair or a candy bar pillow?
54. Would you rather have orange hair for Halloween or purple hair?
55. Would you rather have a pumpkin backpack or a candy-shaped backpack?
56. Would you rather have Halloween music play every time you enter a room or have a pumpkin decoration follow you?
57. Would you rather accidentally get 100 pieces of the same candy or 100 completely different candies?
58. Would you rather wear a costume that is three sizes too big or one that is three sizes too small?
59. Would you rather have to wear a pumpkin hat for a month or Halloween socks for a year?
60. Would you rather have your Halloween candy make a funny sound every time you open the bag or glow in the dark?

🧸 Kids’ Favorite Things

61. Would you rather have a mystery squishy dumpling or a NeeDoh?
62. Would you rather have a Squeeezy Butter or a Squeeezy Banana?
63. Would you rather have a giant collection of squishies or a giant collection of candy?
64. Would you rather get a new squishy or your favorite candy?
65. Would you rather have Target release a new squishy toy of your face or have spiderman fly you to school?
66. Would you rather have a candy-colored bedroom or a pumpkin-themed bedroom?
67. Would you rather have Halloween pajamas or Halloween slippers?
68. Would you rather get a new game or a giant bag of candy?
69. Would you rather have a Halloween stuffed animal or a giant squishy?
70. Would you rather have a Halloween craft kit or a Halloween game?

🚗 Silly Halloween Adventures

71. Would you rather drive a pumpkin car to school or ride a dragon to school?
72. Would you rather travel to school in a giant candy bar or a giant pumpkin?
73. Would you rather have a pumpkin-shaped treehouse or a candy-shaped treehouse?
74. Would you rather have a candy castle or a pumpkin castle?
75. Would you rather have your own pumpkin farm or candy factory?
76. Would you rather have a giant Halloween parade in your neighborhood or a giant Halloween party?
77. Would you rather ride in a pumpkin-shaped hot air balloon or a candy-shaped hot air balloon?
78. Would you rather have a Halloween-themed bedroom or Halloween-themed backyard?
79. Would you rather have a Halloween food truck or a Halloween candy truck?
80. Would you rather be able to make any food turn into candy or any drink turn into a milkshake?

🧁 Halloween Food Questions

81. Would you rather have Halloween cupcakes or Halloween donuts?
82. Would you rather have caramel apples or candy apples?
83. Would you rather have pumpkin pancakes or pumpkin waffles?
84. Would you rather have Halloween pizza or Halloween tacos?
85. Would you rather have hot chocolate or apple cider?
86. Would you rather have a giant bowl of popcorn or a giant bowl of candy?
87. Would you rather eat a pumpkin-shaped cookie or pumpkin-shaped pancake?
88. Would you rather have orange cupcakes or purple cupcakes?
89. Would you rather make a giant caramel apple or giant Halloween cookie?
90. Would you rather have a Halloween breakfast party or Halloween dessert party?

🍂 Last 10 Halloween Would You Rather Questions

91. Would you rather have your own candy-making factory or your own pumpkin farm?
92. Would you rather have the best Halloween costume in town or the biggest candy collection?
93. Would you rather have unlimited Halloween games or unlimited Halloween snacks?
94. Would you rather have your pet pick your costume or your best friend pick it?
95. Would you rather have a Halloween sleepover with your friends or a huge Halloween party?
96. Would you rather find $20 in your Halloween candy bag or your favorite candy in every house?
97. Would you rather have Halloween all year long or only celebrate it once a year?
98. Would you rather be able to make pumpkins grow instantly or make candy appear instantly?
99. Would you rather have a candy-themed Halloween or a pumpkin-themed Halloween?
100. Would you rather have the best Halloween ever or the best Halloween candy ever?

🎃 More Non-Scary Halloween Fun

Play Planners is centered around Christianity, family, friendship, and making happy memories together. For us, Christianity isn’t something that we only focus on at certain times of the year—it’s a lifestyle that children learn to follow and live out in every season.

Because of that, I don’t believe in intentionally encouraging fear in children or making Halloween about things that are dark or frightening. Instead, I love focusing on the fun, wholesome parts of the season: candy, costumes, pumpkins, games, crafts, laughter, and time together. 🎃🍬

Halloween can be a great opportunity to make sweet memories with the people you love without participating in themes that don’t align with your family’s values. That’s why you’ll find plenty of non-scary, family-friendly Halloween activities for kids here at Play Planners. ❤️

Try pairing these Halloween Would You Rather questions with:

• Halloween candy word searches
• Halloween bingo
• Halloween I Spy
• Pumpkin decorating
• Halloween scavenger hunts
• Halloween coloring pages
• Halloween crafts
• Candy-themed games
• Halloween baking
• Pumpkin activities

🍬 Try the Printable Version

Want to turn these questions into an easy Halloween activity?

I also have a Halloween Would You Rather printable that kids can complete by underlining their answers and comparing them with friends.

It’s perfect for Halloween classrooms, parties, babysitting, homeschool, playdates, and family activities.

So grab some Halloween candy, pick your favorite questions, and start comparing answers!

Happy Halloween! 🎃🍬

---

Want more Halloween activities?